And if it could be that easy, wouldn’t more people buy homes? And wouldn’t those buyers need to fill their homes with lamps and blenders and sectional couches with hand-lathed wooden legs? And wouldn’t that mean all sorts of wooden leg making opportunities for wooden leg makers? And wouldn’t those new leg makers own phones from which they could quickly and easily secure mortgages of their own, further stoking demand for necessary household goods as our tidal wave of ownership floods the country with new homeowners who now must own other things. And isn’t that the power of America itself?
The advertisement for Rocket Mortgage is visually compelling and calls upon tried and true cultural tropes. Why then, was it not persuasive? Let’s take a closer look:
DETAIWIN Women Casual Boat Loafers shoes Slip On Soft PU Leather Comfort Shallow Square Toe Single Ballet Flats
“What We Were Thinking” has a strong, consistent cadence throughout. The guitar in the background music is a driving beat. Even when other sounds are laid on top, the underlying sound remains the same – and it’s one that creates a feeling of both urgency and forward motion.
The ad’s narrator does the same thing with her words. She strings together a chain of questions, each beginning with the word “and.” Each question appears to follow from the previous, and together they build a progress narrative:
It’s possible for someone to argue with the premises of any of these questions or with the conclusions they imply, but the narrator does not pause between them to allow this. Instead, her cadence paired with the linked questions fosters a sense of inevitability.
Smart.A Womens Office Party Sweet Lolita Chunky High Heel PU Lace up Ankle Boots
It could seem strange to end this series with “And isn’t that the power of America itself?,” but the progress narrative is so key to the American mythos, and so reliant on notions of inevitability, that it makes sense here. In response to criticism of the ad, Quicken’s chief marketing officer said, “I think that everyone is realizing it’s time for the housing industry to advance.” Quicken Loans is not just selling houses, it’s selling a very particular understanding of progress, one rooted in consumption, accumulation, ownership. Indeed, the American Dream, our leading progress narrative in the U.S., is often defined first in terms of ownership, via “a house with a white picket fence.”
Womens Cartoon Kitty Cat Meow Breathable Sneakers
All of this is accompanied by a sense of “no big deal.” The ad’s narrator begins with, “Here’s what we were thinking,” and ends with, “anyway, that’s what we were thinking.” It feels nonchalant, makes it sound like the narrative is just common sense. The mundanity of the activities depicted in the commercial contribute to this feeling: people at a movie, people doing their jobs, people at an exercise class, a woman carrying her baby in the kitchen. These are everyday activities for everyday folks. They are common. In the Quicken ad, progress is common sense. Ownership is common sense.Caparros Dalton Womens Size 6.5 Black Peep Toe Dress Sandals shoes
Owaheson Platform Lace up Sneaker Casual Chunky Walking shoes High Top Women colorful SeaweedOwaheson Platform Lace up Sneaker Casual Chunky Walking shoes High Top Women Latvia Flag National EmblemOwaheson Platform Lace up Sneaker Casual Chunky Walking shoes High Top Women Democratic Republic of Congo Flag
Women's shoes PU Spring Summer shoes Sandals Chunky Heel Peep Toe Buckle for Casual Dress Party & Evening
Aerosoles Womens Ms Softee Moccasin
August Jim Women Ballet Flats Pointy Toe Slip on Retro Ruffled Classic Flat Walking shoesQiyun Faux PU Leather Chunky Platform Women Lace-Up Warm Ankle Boots Casual shoes shoes BottesNature Breeze Women Mix Media Lace Mesh Lace Up Sneaker CA78 - Fuchsia
Given these well worn tropes, one would expect the viewing public to be on board with Rocket Mortgages. But here’s the thing: the message doesn’t match the audience’s experience.
Early in the commercial, as the app promises to “turn an intimidating process into an easy one,” a magician appears on the screen with fireworks and a woman sawed in half. This visual misstep serves as a reminder that what appears to be easy, what is advertised as common sense, is often an illusion. There is not a single scene in which people look at each other during the ad, apart from the one containing the magician, who looks directly at the viewer. It is as though he is trying to hypnotize the audience into buying what Quicken is selling.
August Jim Suede shoes for Women,Round Toe Flats,Womens Office Work shoes Slip onRainbow high heels High-Heeled shoes for Women - Rainbow 2018 New, 6cm Thick Heel Sandals Women's Word Buttons Baotou shoesgolden Road G.N.D Women Shinny Flowers Summer Lady's Sandal JS60